IOLTA or a Separate Client Trust Account? A Worked Example and a Re-Check Routine for California Firms
By Tammy Hoang, Certified QuickBooks ProAdvisor

Every time a California firm receives client money, someone decides where it goes: the pooled IOLTA account, or a separate client trust account that earns interest for that one client. The decision is easy to get wrong, because it depends on numbers most firms never write down.
This guide shows the rule California uses, walks through a worked example with two deposits and two different answers, explains the three factors to weigh, and covers what to do when the facts change and the money needs to move.
If you want the basic comparison first, read our guide to individual client trust accounts vs. IOLTA. This article adds the math and the routine.
The Test California Uses: Can the Funds Earn Net Income for the Client?
California does not use a dollar threshold. The State Bar's trust account guidelines say that client funds that are nominal in amount, or on deposit for such a short time that they cannot earn net income for the client, must go into a pooled IOLTA, with the interest paid to the State Bar. Client funds that can earn revenue for the client in excess of the costs to hold the account must go into a non-IOLTA trust account, so that all of the interest goes to the client.
The guidelines point to Rule 2.110(A) of the Rules of the State Bar for the factors to consider, and they say your financial institution can help you evaluate whether income for the client is possible. In plain terms, the test asks whether the interest a separate account would earn is larger than what it costs to open, hold and account for it.
That is why the answer changes from client to client. One firm can hold a small retainer in the IOLTA for one client and a large settlement in its own account for another, and both can be correct.
Good IOLTA bookkeeping starts with this sorting step, because every later control depends on money being in the right account. Law firm trust accounting also benefits from a written answer: when someone asks why a deposit went where it did, your records should say.
Irvine law firm bookkeeping clients often tell us the hardest part is not the math but remembering to do it at deposit time. California law firm bookkeeping that builds the check into the intake routine solves that, and Orange County firms with busy settlement calendars benefit most.
A Worked Example: Two Deposits, Two Different Answers

The numbers below are illustrations, not current rates or bank fees. Use your own bank's actual rate and fee schedule. The method is what matters.
Deposit A: $60,000 for nine months. At an assumed 3.00% a year, nine months of interest is about $1,350 before costs. If the bank charges an assumed $20 a month for the separate account, nine months of fees is $180. That leaves about $1,170 of net income for the client, and time spent on extra reconciliations and statements still has to be weighed against it. The funds look like candidates for a separate account.
Deposit B: $2,500 for two weeks. At the same assumed rate, two weeks of interest is under $3. One month of the assumed fee would be $20. There is no net income to earn, so the funds belong in the IOLTA.
Between those extremes is a gray zone: a mid-sized deposit held for a few months, or a large deposit that may be disbursed next week. In the gray zone, the holding period is usually the swing factor, so estimate it honestly and write down the estimate.
A decision like this should leave a trace. Our guide to IOLTA vs. escrow differences gives another view of the same choice.
Legal bookkeeping services that record the decision for each deposit give attorneys something concrete to review, and attorney client trust account rules are easier to follow when the choice of account is written down.
The Three Factors, One at a Time

Projected interest versus expected costs. Estimate interest from the amount, the rate the bank quotes and the days expected. Estimate costs from the bank's fee schedule and from the extra work of a second ledger, a second reconciliation and year-end interest reporting. If interest does not clearly exceed costs, that points to the IOLTA.
How long you will hold the funds. A deposit that clears in days rarely earns anything. A deposit tied to a long case, a payment plan or a pending lien negotiation may sit for months. Ask the responsible attorney for a realistic range, not the best case.
What your bank can actually do. Ask whether the bank will open an account for one client, how it handles the client's taxpayer identification, how statements are produced and what fees and minimums apply. The State Bar's guidelines note that a non-IOLTA account for one client carries that client's taxpayer identification, with the interest accruing to the client. Do not assume every bank offers sub-accounts. Ask and get the answer in writing.
Weighing these factors does not need to be complicated. It needs to be done at the time of the deposit and recorded, so that the decision is something you made and not a habit.
California IOLTA compliance and CTAPP compliance both depend on knowing which accounts hold client money. A firm that keeps both kinds of accounts should list every one of them on the same compliance calendar.
Not sure where a client's funds belong?
Irvine Bookkeeping can help you run the numbers and set up the right account.
Good IOLTA bookkeeping services also watch for the reverse problem. A client whose funds sit in a separate account long after the matter has slowed needs the same monthly attention as any other balance, and a client trust account reconciliation should show the account as active, not forgotten.
When the Facts Change: Moving Funds Between Accounts

The first decision is not always the last one. A settlement that was supposed to fund next week may stall. A deposit that went to the IOLTA because it was expected to be short-term may turn into a long hold. When that happens, ask the question again.
Review points worth building into your routine:
When the expected disbursement date moves by more than a few weeks.
When more money is added to a client's balance in the IOLTA.
At each monthly reconciliation, for any client with a large balance that has not moved.
If the answer changes, move the money with a clear paper trail. A careful order of steps looks like this:
Document the reason and have the responsible attorney approve the move.
Open the separate account for that client, with the client's taxpayer identification, and confirm the bank's terms.
Record the transfer as a disbursement on the client's IOLTA ledger and a deposit on the new account's ledger, on the same date.
Reconcile both accounts for the month of the transfer and attach the transfer record.
This is a practical sequence, not a State Bar requirement. Your bank and your ethics counsel may have additional steps.
California IOLTA compliance and CTAPP compliance are easier to support when the records for both account types are kept the same way, and attorney client trust account rules apply to both.
The Records Each Account Needs

Both account types fall under Rule 1.15, which requires a trust account labeled as such, a ledger for each client, a journal for each account, bank statements and cancelled checks, and a monthly reconciliation, kept for five years. A separate client trust account adds one more thing: interest that belongs to the client and must be posted to that client's ledger.
A one-page decision log for each deposit is enough. Record the date, the amount, the expected holding period, the interest and cost estimates, the bank's input, the decision, who made it and the date it will be reviewed again.
Attorney trust account bookkeeping for a separate account follows the same monthly rhythm as the IOLTA: a client trust account reconciliation that ties the bank statement, the journal and the client ledger together.
See our three-way reconciliation guide for California law firms for the monthly routine.
Also remember reporting. The State Bar's guidelines require a new or closed trust account to be updated in My State Bar Profile within 30 days. Review the State Bar's client trust account guidelines and the text of Rule 1.15 for the current requirements.
Ask your CPA how interest earned in a client's account is reported for tax purposes. That question is outside the scope of bookkeeping, and the answer depends on the facts.
How Irvine Bookkeeping Helps Law Firms Choose and Track the Right Account?

Irvine Bookkeeping provides bookkeeping for law firms in Irvine and Orange County, including IOLTA bookkeeping and monthly reconciliation. Our IOLTA bookkeeping services include setting up client ledgers for each account and keeping the decision log current.
As an Irvine law firm bookkeeping team led by a Certified QuickBooks ProAdvisor, we deliver legal bookkeeping services and California law firm bookkeeping that support California IOLTA compliance and CTAPP compliance. Our attorney trust account bookkeeping and law firm trust accounting follow the attorney client trust account rules, with a documented client trust account reconciliation each month.
Our IOLTA bookkeeping services, attorney trust account bookkeeping and legal bookkeeping services handle the extra ledgers a separate account needs, so the attorney sees one clear monthly package covering every trust account the firm holds.
Strong IOLTA bookkeeping, steady California law firm bookkeeping and careful law firm trust accounting make the account decision easy to explain later. Orange County attorneys who are not sure how a recent deposit was classified can send us the details and we will walk through it with them.
Irvine law firm bookkeeping and California law firm bookkeeping teams that work in Orange County also help firms prepare each monthly client trust account reconciliation for attorney review. Legal bookkeeping services of this kind turn a one-time decision into a routine.
The point is simple: put each client's money where the numbers say it belongs, and keep the numbers on file.
Talk with an Irvine law firm bookkeeping specialist
Tell us about your trust accounts and we will review them with you.




Very informative article! The practical examples make the differences between trust accounts and IOLTA much easier to understand. Geometry Dash is also a fun game to enjoy during a short break.